Myths versus facts
Twelve tidy ideas, and the official wording that will not tidy them
A first look at Iguanodon often wants one length, one month, and one use for the thumb. The museums do not always offer that kindness.
Myth
The spike was always known to be a thumb.
Official wording
The horn “was still a prevailing theory when Owen consulted on the construction of the Crystal Palace dinosaur sculptures in the 1850s.” “It wasn’t until a significant Iguanodon discovery was made in the 1870s that it was proved that the spikes were thumbs rather than horns.” [source]
Myth
The modern length of Iguanodon is one official figure, so 10.0 m, about 10 metres, and 9 to 11 metres can be averaged.
Official wording
The directory gives 10.0 m. The discovery page says “about 10 metres.” The Belgian masterpiece page, for Iguanodon bernissartensis, gives adults “between 9 and 11 metres long.” This desk does not invent a fourth length. [source]
Myth
4000 kg and around 8 tonnes are the same official weight, written two ways.
Official wording
The directory’s weight is 4000 kg. The masterpiece page’s weight, for that species, is “around 8 tonnes.” The two figures are left in their own sentences. [source]
Myth
140–110 million years and 126–122 million years are the same range, narrowed.
Official wording
The directory and the discovery page use 140–110 million years. The masterpiece page dates Iguanodon bernissartensis to 126–122 million years ago. The narrower range is not used here to overwrite the wider one. [source]
Myth
Mary Ann Mantell’s roadside find is a settled fact, without a hedge.
Official wording
The museum’s wording is “Most accounts hold that Mary was accompanying her husband on a trip to visit a patient in Sussex, when she noticed something glinting by the side of the road.” The hedge stays in the sentence. [source]
Myth
The early 18-metre estimate is still the official living length.
Official wording
Scaled up from an iguana, “the prehistoric owner of the fossilised teeth could have been up to 18 metres or longer.” The next official sentence is: “We now know this dinosaur reached a length of about 10 metres.” [source]
Myth
The Maidstone slab should be relabelled as Mantellisaurus on this site’s authority.
Official wording
The museum calls it “the Maidstone Slab, also known as the Mantell-piece,” and says Gideon “attributed the bones to Iguanodon.” Later splitting of English material, including Mantellisaurus atherfieldensis, is told separately. This site does not retitle the slab on its own authority. [source]
Myth
The 1882 bipedal mounts show how Iguanodon walked in life, so later wording can be ignored.
Official wording
The puzzles “were assembled based on knowledge of the time, that Iguanodon was bipedal. We now know the dinosaur predominantly walked on all fours.” The mounts “are now too fragile to be repositioned.” A masterpiece page still says locomotion is “still debated.” [source]
Myth
The glass-case lengths of 629 to 730 centimetres are a third official estimate of the living animal.
Official wording
The glance page is measuring “the iguanodons in the glass case,” which “range from 629 to 730cm long and 390 to 506cm high.” Those figures are mount measurements, not a living-animal estimate to set beside 10.0 m or 9 to 11 metres. [source]
Myth
Mantell’s 1825 name and the 1881 type-species credit cannot both be official, so one must be dropped.
Official wording
The search article dates the naming of Iguanodon to 1825. The directory’s type species, bernissartensis, is “named by Boulenger and van Beneden (1881).” One is a genus name, the other a type-species credit. This desk keeps both. [source]
Myth
The discovery in the mine has one official month, so March and April should be merged.
Official wording
The Natural History Museum dates a chance discovery to March 1878. The glance page starts “at the end of March 1878” and dates the telegram 12 April 1878. The masterpiece page says the first bones were discovered in April 1878. The months stay as written. [source]
Myth
The dinner inside the sculpture and a file caption that says “revealed in 1854” fix a single official opening year.
Official wording
The museum dates the dinner “prior to the completion of the Crystal Palace dinosaurs in 1853.” A Commons file caption for a scale model says the original “was revealed in 1854.” Those wordings are kept apart, and the file is not used to overwrite the museum. [source]
Enjoyed this desk on a horn that became a thumb, and a mine full of Iguanodons?
No pop-ups. No intrusive advertising. Just interesting stuff. A little support helps the next dinosaurs.im site get built.